Brocki, brocante, second-hand shop or flea market: what is the difference?
In Switzerland you can buy second-hand goods in many places: at a Brocki, a brocante, a second-hand shop, a flea market or an antique dealer. The terms overlap, but each place has its own typical character.
Updated:
Why the terms often blur
When people say "Brocki", they do not always mean the same thing. Some shops call themselves a Brockenhaus and mainly sell vintage furniture, while others call themselves second-hand and work like a classic Brocki. The names are not strict categories but describe tendencies. The differences below therefore apply often or usually, but not in every single case.
As a customer, and even more so if you want to donate or sell something, it is still worth knowing the typical models. They differ mainly in where the goods come from, who runs the shop and where the proceeds go.
Brockenhaus or Brocki
A Brockenhaus, or "Brocki" for short in Switzerland, is a warehouse for second-hand goods, similar to what is called a thrift store or charity shop elsewhere. From dining tables to crockery to bikes, you can find almost anything there, often for just a few francs. Typical features are:
- Donations as the basis: the goods mostly come from private individuals who pass things on rather than throwing them away.
- Non-profit operators: many Brockis are run by associations, foundations, church organisations or social institutions. The proceeds fund social projects or jobs that help people back into work.
- Wide range: furniture, household goods, books, clothes, toys and decorations under one roof.
There are also private operators who combine second-hand trading with clearances and disposal. You can read more about the history and the name in What is a Brocki?
Brocante: the term from French-speaking Switzerland
"Brocante" is the French word for bric-a-brac and is used mainly in Romandy, the French-speaking part of Switzerland. In everyday use, it sometimes also refers to shops that resemble a Brocki. Often, though, the term stands for a somewhat different concept:
- The focus is often on bric-a-brac, vintage and decorations: old tools, enamel signs, crockery with patina, furniture with character.
- Brocantes are frequently run privately. The goods are more likely to be bought in or gathered during clearances than donated.
- The selection is usually more curated, and the prices reflect that.
The word "brocante" also crops up in German-speaking Switzerland, for example as a name for vintage shops or markets with decorative items.
Second-hand shop
"Second-hand" is an umbrella term for anything previously owned. As a type of shop, it usually means a specialised business: clothes, children's items, sports equipment, designer fashion or electronics.
A common model is selling on consignment. You bring in your goods, the shop displays and sells them. If something sells, you share the proceeds with the shop. Anything not sold after an agreed period you collect again or leave to the shop. Each business sets its own exact terms.
Unlike at a Brocki, you may therefore get money for your things here. In return, the shop is usually stricter about what it accepts.
Flea markets and the antiques trade
Flea market
At a flea market, it is mostly private individuals selling their own things, sometimes alongside dealers. Markets are held temporarily, for instance on certain weekends or during the warmer months. Haggling is often part of the experience, and payment is frequently in cash. The offer is a colourful mix and depends entirely on who has a stall that day.
Antiques trade
Antique dealers are specialist shops. They know about periods, styles, materials and makers, check where pieces come from and often have them professionally restored. This expertise comes at a price: antiques tend to cost considerably more than furniture at a Brocki. In return, you usually get a well-founded assessment of the piece.
There is some overlap between the two worlds. Some Brockis have their own corner for older pieces; you will find a selection under Brockis with antiques.
Comparison by criteria
Where the goods come from
- Brocki: mostly donations from private individuals
- Brocante: often bought in, from clearances or sourced by the owner
- Second-hand shop: frequently consignment goods or bought in
- Flea market: the sellers' own belongings
- Antiques trade: selective buying, often from estates or collections
Prices
- Brocki: usually cheap, often just a few francs
- Brocante: rather higher, depending on rarity and condition
- Second-hand shop: depends on brand and specialisation
- Flea market: negotiable, varying widely
- Antiques trade: tends to be the highest, but with expert knowledge
Who runs it
- Brocki: often non-profit, sometimes private
- Brocante: frequently privately run
- Second-hand shop: mostly private, sometimes charities
- Flea market: private individuals, organised by associations, communes or event organisers
- Antiques trade: private specialist shop
Range
- Brocki: very wide, from furniture to books
- Brocante: bric-a-brac, vintage and decorations
- Second-hand shop: often specialised, for example in clothes
- Flea market: a colourful mix that is different every time
- Antiques trade: selected older pieces with a history
Which place suits what you need?
The question is less which place is better and more what you have in mind. This checklist helps you choose:
- You are looking for affordable furniture or household goods: a Brocki is usually the first port of call. With the Brocki search by town and canton you can find shops near you.
- You want to pass things on without expecting money for them: a donation to a Brocki often supports a social cause at the same time. Find out how in Donating furniture to a Brocki.
- You want to sell something: a second-hand shop working on consignment or a flea market stall is a better fit.
- You are looking for decorations or pieces with patina: brocantes and vintage shops are often exciting places for that.
- You want to know the value of an heirloom: ask an expert in the antiques trade.
- An entire flat has to be emptied: then a clearance with a quote is usually simpler than lots of separate trips.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Brocki the same as a brocante?
Not quite. A Brocki is often non-profit and relies on donations, while a brocante is frequently privately run and geared more towards bric-a-brac, vintage and decorations. In everyday use, though, the terms are sometimes used interchangeably.
Will I get money for my things at a Brocki?
Usually not, because most Brockis rely on donations. If you want to sell something, a second-hand shop working on consignment or a flea market is a better choice.
What does consignment mean at a second-hand shop?
The shop sells your goods on your behalf and keeps part of the proceeds if they sell. Each business sets its own exact terms and deadlines.
Where is it cheapest?
Brockis and flea markets are usually the cheapest. Prices at brocantes and in the antiques trade tend to be higher, but the selection is more curated.
Are there antiques at a Brocki too?
Sometimes, yes. Some Brockis have their own corner for older pieces, but you usually will not get an expert valuation there as you would in the antiques trade.